I'm also battling back and forth on this one, too. I love the window, all chipped and rugged, but where is the line for this style? At what point is it a beautiful pairing of worn pieces and at what point is it just junky? I want to live with beautiful things around me, not things I made to look decrepit.
And I love the top part of that sink, with its slope and basin, but am hating the bare pipes.